The Mkwawa Portrait Conundrum: A Quest for Facial Similitude
Abstract
This paper reports the findings of an investigation that was carried out to determine the accuracy of the facial likeness of Paramount Chief Mkwawa to his representative portrait created in 1954, with the intent to complement the missing part of his face following the return of his skull from Germany where it had been kept for 56 years. Since its creation, the portrait sought to approximate the actual face of Mkwawa, which had been badly damaged from a gunshot wound and the ensuing maceration process by Tom von Prince before he shipped the skull to Bremen, Germany in July 1898. Since its return to the then Tanganyika, local and foreign researchers have engaged in endless debate on its authenticity while ignoring discussions on Mkwawa’s facial appearance in most of their publications on the topic. Employing the Imitation Theory of Art, this paper extends the inquiry on the legitimacy of Mkwawa’s skull to his portrait, created to complement the missing flesh on the skull. Data for the study had been collected using critical interviews and document review. Meanwhile, analysis entailed a comparative examination of the facial features on the original photograph of Mkwawa’s head against photographs of his lineal descendants. Besides, a review was carried out of the artist’s skills of portraiture and knowledge of principles of art, as well as narratives of the respondents on the portrait creation process. Findings show that the portrait depicted a striking facial resemblance to Mkwawa’s descendants involved in his portrait creation process except for the spiritual aura and the imagined facial expression of the paramount Chief himself.
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Achebe, C. 1975, Morning yet on a creation day: Essays, Heinemann Educational, London.
Baer, M., & Schröter, O. 2001, Eine Kopfjagd - Deutsche in Ostafrika, Christoph Links Verlag, Berlin.
Blier, S. P. 2012. Art in ancient Ife, birthplace of the Yoruba. African Arts, Winter, vol. 45, no. 4, pp. 70–85, https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/blier/files/blier.pdf. Accessed on 11 September 2022.
Borgatti, J. M. 1990, Portraiture in Africa African Arts, Portraiture in Africa, Part I. Vol.23, no. 3, Special Issue, pp. 34-39+101.
Borgatti, J. M. 2019, Constructed identities: portraiture in world art. World Art Studies IV Comparative Approaches. https://pdfcookie.com/documents/constructed-identities-portraiture-in-world-art-j9lgq3ynyrvo. Accessed on 11 September 2022
Bortolot, A. I. 2003, Portraits of African leadership: royal ancestors, in Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000–, New York. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/aprt_2/hd_aprt_2.htm. Accessed on 12 September 2022.
Brockmeyer, B. et al. 2020, The Mkwawa complex: a Tanzanian-European history about provenance, restitution, and politics. Journal of Modern European History, pp.1–23, retrieved from; https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1611894420909033 on Oct. 27, 2022.
Buti, L., Gruppioni, G., & Benazzi, S. 2017, Facial reconstruction of famous historical figures: Between science and art, Cambridge University Press, London.
Branfoot, C. (Ed.) 2018, Portraiture in South Asia since the Mughals: Art, representation and history, Bloomsbury Academic Press, London.
Carney, J. D. 1994. A Historical Theory of Art Criticism. Journal of Aesthetic Education, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 13–29. https://doi.org/10.2307/3333153.
Cartwright, C. 2020. Depicting the dead: Ancient Egyptian mummy portraits. The British Museum, October 17 (Blog), https://blog.britishmuseum.org/depicting-the-dead-ancient-egyptian-mummy-portraits/. Accessed on 11 September 2022.
Chalençon, P. J. 2007, NAPOLÉON an Intimate Portrait, Oklahoma City Museum of Art, February 1 - April 22, [Exhibition catalogue], Florida, Russell Etling Co. Retrieved from: https://www.okcmoa.com/wpcontent/uploads/2013/04/Napoleon_Teachers_Packet.pdf on 27 October 2022.
Ching, D. C. Y. 2015, The Language of portraiture in China, in M. J. Powers and K. R. Tsiang (Eds.). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118885215.ch6. Accessed on 11 September 2022.
Christiansen, K., & Weppelmann, S. (Eds.) 2011, The renaissance portrait from Donatello to Bellini, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
Crema, E. 1987, Wahehe: a Bantu people, Italian Missionary Press, Bologna.
Description of 'Memoir of Teddy (Z.E.) and Dorothy Kingdon, [c1980-2000]. Bodleian Library, University of Oxford. GB 161 MSS. AFR. S. 2255' on the Archives Hub website, https://archiveshub.jisc.ac.uk/data/gb161-mss.afr.s.2255. Accessed on 09/08/2022
Desplat, J. 2019, The skull of Sultan Mkwawa. The National Archives, Thursday 19 July (Blog), https://blog.nationalarchives.gov.uk/the-skull-of-sultan-mkwawa/ accessed on 30 August 2022.
El-Hema, A.H.B. 2012, Uislamu wa Mkwawa: Chifu wa Wahehe Islamic Sites Conservation, Dar es Salaam.
Foote, H. W. 1941, False faces: A study of the use and misuse of portraits as historical documents, Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society, vol. 67, pp. 562–579. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25080365.
Garsha, J. J. 2018, Fuvu la kichwa cha Mkwawa. (The Skull of Mkwawa’s Head), Doing History in Public (Blog), 4 December. https://doinghistoryinpublic.org/2018/12/04/4-fuvu-la-kichwa-cha-mkwawa-the-skull-of-mkwawas-head/ 31 August 2022
Garsha, J. J. 2019, The head of Chief Mkwawa and the transnational history of colonial violence. 1898-2019…
Gisbey, P. J. C. K. 2019, What the Renaissance was and why it still matters: Renaissance primer. (1 of 2), Thesis. University of Cambridge, DOI:10.13140/RG.2.2.27417.67688.
Kingdon, J. 2022, E-mail to Dominicus Zimanimoto Makukula, 27 July
Koch, E. 2018. Jahangir as Publius Scipio Maior: The commensurability of Mughal political portraiture, in C. Branfoot (Ed). Portraiture in South Asia since the Mughals: Art, representation, and history. Retrieved from: https://www.academia.edu/38475653/Jahangir_as_Publius_Scipio_Maior_The_Commensurability_of_Mughal_Political_Portraiture on 27 October 2022.
Le Gall, Y., & Mboro, M. S. 2019, Remembering the dismembered African human remains and memory cultures in and after repatriation. Ph.D. Thesis: https://doi.org/10.25932/publishup-50850, University of Potsdam, Germany.
Longford, M. 2001, The flags changed at midnight: Tanganyika's progress towards independence, 24, Gracewing Publishing, Herefordshire.
Malangalila, F. F. A. 1987, MWAMUYINGA, Mtawala wa Wahehe, Peramiho: Benedictine Publications, Ndanda.
Makukula, D. Z. 2019, The development of visual arts in Tanzania from 1961 to 2015: A focus on the national cultural policy and institutions influences. Ph.D. Thesis. http://dx.doi.org/10.17169/refubium-4095 Freie Universität Berlin, Germany.
Mathijs & Mosselmans, 2000, Mimesis and the representation of reality: A historical world view. Foundations of Science, vol. 5 pp. 61–102, Kluwer Academic Publishers. https://www.academia.edu/ 9356360/ Mimesis_and_the_Representation_of_Reality_ A_Historical_World_View
Miles, E. G. 1983, Portraits of the heroes of Louisbourg, 1745-175. The American Art Journal, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 48-66 https://www.jstor.org/stable/1594346.
Miller, J. D. 1972, Contemporary artists in East Africa. Kenya Past and Present, (1) 2 https://journals.co.za/doi/pdf/10.10520/AJA02578301_19. Accessed on 12 September 2022.
Moore, C. A. 2017, Facial expression as key to narrative portraiture. catherineannemoore.medium.com, 17 July. https://catherineannemoore.medium.com/facial-expression-as-key-to-narrative-portraiture-6c1dd2e7655f. Accessed on 25 august 2022.
Musso, M. 2011, Mukwavinyika Mwamuyinga na kabila lake la Wahehe, Dar es Salaam University Press, Dar es salaam.
Nigmann, E. 1908, Die Wahehe, Ernst Siegfrid Mittler und Sohn, Berlin.
Prince, T. 1914, Gegen Araber und Wahehe: Erinnerungen aus meiner ostafrikanischen Leutnantszeit 1890-1895, Berlin, E.S. Mittler
Redmayne, A. 1964, The Wahehe people of Tanganyika, Ph.D. Thesis, Nuffield College.
Redmayne, A. (1968), Mkwawa and the Hehe wars. The Journal of African History, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 409–436. http://www.jstor.org/stable/180274.
Shamil, J. 2017. Nose types - personality, ethnicity, and ancestry”, DR. SHAMIL SMART LIVING, 27 September. http://drshamilsmartliving.blogspot.com/2017/09/nose-types-personality-ethnicity-and.html. Accessed on 25 August 2022
Soetan, S. O., & Osadola, O. 2018, Historic preservation: prospects and challenges, IJRISS, vol. 2, no. 5, pp.53-56, https://www.rsisinternational.org/journals/ijriss/Digital-Library/volume-2-issue-5/53-56.pdf
Suh, Y. 2013, Past looking: using arts as historical evidence in teaching history, Social Studies Research, and Practice, vol. 8, no. 1., pp. 139-159, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/SSRP-01-2013-B0010.
Tate, J. 2017, Art term: Portrait. Accessed 11 August 2022, https://www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/p/portrait
Tate, J. 1939, Plato and “Imitation,” The Classical Quarterly, vol. 26, no. 3/4, pp. 161–169, DOI: http://www.jstor.org/stable/636756
Trapp, J. B. 2001, Petrarch’s Laura: the portraiture of an imaginary beloved. Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, vol. 64, pp. 55–192. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/751561
Van Wagenberg-Ter Hoeven, A. A. 2005, A matter of mistaken identity. In search of a new title for Rubens’s “Tiberius and Agrippina.” Artibus et Historiae, vol. 26, no. 52, pp. 113–127. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/20067100.
Prince, M. 1908, Eine Deutsche Frau im Innern Deutsch-Ostafrikas (3rd ed.), Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn, Berlin.
Prince, T. 1914, Gegen Araber und Wahehe: erinnerungen aus meiner ostafrikanischen Leutnantszeit 1890-1895, Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn, Berlin.
Wango, K. 2020, The role of hyperrealism in painted portraiture –engaging culture: Analysis of Portraiture by Eddy Ochieng. East African Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 157-179. DOI: https://doi.org/10.37284/eajis.2.1.246.
Winans, E. V. 1994, The head of the king: museums and the path to resistance. Comparative Studies in Society and History, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 221-241. http://jstor.org/stable/179258
Woods-Marsden, J. 2013, The meaning of the European painted portrait, 1400–1650, in B. Bohn, & J. M. Saslow (Eds.), A Companion to Renaissance and Baroque Art, John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Xu, Y., Li, X., Yang, J., & Zhang, D. 2014, Integrate the original face image and its mirror image for face recognition, Neurocomputing, vol. 131, pp. 191–199 DOI:10.1016/j.neucom.2013.10.025.